Record: 32-4, 15-1 (1st place)
ACC Tournament: Lost in final
NCAA Tournament: Lost in Elite 8
Final AP Ranking: 3
All-ACC Players: Roshown McLeod (1st), Trajan Langdon (1st), Steve Wojciechowski (3rd)
All-Americans: None
The 1995 season was a disaster for the Duke program. The narrative is well known. Coach K had back surgery, tried to come back too soon, and had to be shut down for the season. The team was turned over to Pete Gaudet. Unfortunately for his reputation, they fell apart, finishing last in the ACC regular season.
We’ll never know what their record would have been had K been healthy, but make no mistake: this team wasn’t very good. This was not a Top 10 team that Pete Gaudet ran into the ground. Our memories tend to craft narratives that are tidier than reality, and a common one about this team is that 1995 was a one-year aberration. Not exactly. The 1996 team was 18-13, 8-8 and lost to Eastern Michigan in the first round of the NCAA Tournament. There were real problems in the program, and some rebuilding was in order. Give Coach K credit for recognizing this. I’m sure it would have been easy to tell himself that his return would solve everything. But he understood that the program had slipped since the Laettner/Hurley/Hill days. They had to look at the kids they were recruiting.
So starting in 1997, and for the next several years, he went on one of the great multiyear recruiting runs in college basketball history. Let’s take a look at the major recruits and transfers during that period and classify them as All-American, All-ACC, major contributor, or non-impact players or transfers.
| Year | All-American | All-ACC | Major Contributor | Non-Impact/Transfer |
| 1997 | Chris Carrawell | Roshown McLeod Nate James | Mike Chappell | |
| 1998 | Elton Brand Shane Battier | William Avery | Chris Burgess | |
| 1999 | Corey Maggette | |||
| 2000 | Jason Williams Mike Dunleavy | Carlos Boozer | Casey Sanders Nick Horvath | |
| 2001 | Chris Duhon | Andre Sweet | ||
| 2002 | Dahntay Jones Daniel Ewing | |||
| 2003 | JJ Redick Shelden Williams | Shavlik Randolph Sean Dockery | Michael Thompson | |
| 2004 | Luol Deng |
So in this stretch, K signed 24 big-time players. A full 14 of those players – 58% – were All-ACC players. Seven (29%) were All-Americans. Two others, Maggette and Deng, were one-and-done players who almost certainly would have reached All-ACC level had they stayed. So basically over an eight-year period, 2/3 of the players K brought in were All-ACC level players. He was bringing in an average of one All-American and one other All-ACC caliber player per year.
Don’t you wish your coach could do that?
In terms of sheer volume of really good players, it may not equal late 2010s Duke, when K was reloading his team with a handful of elite one-and-done guys every year; but in the context of the time, that’s about as good a recruiting stretch as anybody ever had.
Now, to bring it back to 1998. The 1997 team had been very good, but you get the sense that the hangover from 1995 had not worn off completely. Jeff Capel and Greg Newton were still around, and they were (perhaps to an unfair degree) strongly associated with 1995’s failure. Despite winning the ACC regular season, it was somehow unsurprising when the Blue Devils fell to 4-12 NC State in the first round of the ACC Tournament and were upset by Providence in the second round of the NCAAs. It would be left to the 1998 team to finish the task of restoring Duke to the top of the college basketball world.
Notice was served in the Maui Classic when the Blue Devils toppled #1 Arizona and usurped that ranking for themselves. This was a team that could absolutely bury you. They beat Virginia by 44, Villanova by 28, Maryland (which was ranked) by 32 and 27, Wake by 36 and 31, #12 UCLA by 36.
One team they didn’t bury was Carolina. In fact, they got buried over in Chapel Hill, 97-73, and suffered a similar if less embarrassing fate in the ACC Tournament final. Of course, that 1998 Carolina team with Jamison and Carter was itself a great team that would go on to make the Final Four.
Duke got a tough draw in the NCAA Tournament with eventual champion Kentucky being in their region. The Wildcats were the strongest of the #2 seeds and had a good argument for a #1 seed themselves. They had nearly won the national championship the previous year and had breezed through the 1998 SEC. The game was a classic. Duke led by 17 with 9:30 to go, but sparked by a flurry of threes and a flagrant foul on McLeod, Kentucky stormed back and pulled out an 86-84 victory.
Though they didn’t win the ACC Tournament or reach the Final Four, this was the team that erased any lingering memories from Duke’s mid-1990s mediocrity and re-established them as one of college basketball’s elite programs.